Which supplement has more ingredients: Black Walnut Hulls, 100 Vegan Capsules (450 mg per Capsule) or Black Walnut Hull, Fluid Extract, Alcohol-Free, 2,000 mg, 1 fl oz (30 mL)?

Both products have the same number of active ingredients (1).

Nature's Way Black Walnut Hull vs Nature's Answer Black Walnut Hulls

Side-by-side supplement facts comparison

Buy on iHerb

Nature's Way

Black Walnut Hulls, 100 Vegan Capsules (450 mg per Capsule)

4.8(8,165)·

Highlights - Made with the quality you trust - Botanicals are sourced where they grow best - From the black walnut tree, native to North America

Buy on iHerb

Nature's Answer

Black Walnut Hull, Fluid Extract, Alcohol-Free, 2,000 mg, 1 fl oz (30 mL)

4.9(7,393)·

Our alcohol-free extracts are produced using our cold Bio-Chelated® proprietary extraction process, yielding a Holistically Balanced® Advanced Botanical Fingerprint® extract in the same synergistic ratios as in the plant.

Buy on iHerb

At a Glance

Verdict

Black Walnut Hull provides a higher concentration per serving in a flexible liquid extract, while Black Walnut Hulls offer convenient pre-measured capsules. The trade-off is dosing flexibility versus capsule convenience.

Who each is for

Nature's Way Black Walnut Hull

You want an alcohol-free liquid extract for flexible dosing.
Black Walnut Hull delivers 2,000 mg dry herb equivalent per serving.
You prefer a supplement that can be adjusted by drops.
Black Walnut Hull suits those who avoid capsules.

Nature's Answer Black Walnut Hulls

You want pre-measured capsules for consistent dosing.
Black Walnut Hulls offer 900 mg per serving from two vegan capsules.
You prefer a portable, no-mix supplement form.
Black Walnut Hulls are suitable for vegan diets.

What you get from each

At a Glance

Processing analysis…

Ingredient Comparison

Total mg Per Serving

Black Walnut Hulls, 100 Vegan Capsules (450 mg per Capsule)

Black Walnut Hull, Fluid Extract, Alcohol-Free, 2,000 mg, 1 fl oz (30 mL)

—

50 servings per container

15 servings per container

1 shared ingredients

0 only in Black Walnut Hulls, 100 Vegan Capsules (450 mg per Capsule)

0 only in Black Walnut Hull, Fluid Extract, Alcohol-Free, 2,000 mg, 1 fl oz (30 mL)

Black Walnut Hulls, 100 Vegan Capsules (450 mg per Capsule)

Nature's Way · 2 Capsules

Black Walnut Hulls, 100 Vegan Capsules (450 mg per Capsule)

Nature's Way · 2 Capsules

Ingredient	Amount	DV
Black Walnut (hull)	900 mg	†

† Daily Value not established

Black Walnut Hull, Fluid Extract, Alcohol-Free, 2,000 mg, 1 fl oz (30 mL)

Nature's Answer · 2 mL (approx. 81 drops)

Black Walnut Hull, Fluid Extract, Alcohol-Free, 2,000 mg, 1 fl oz (30 mL)

Nature's Answer · 2 mL (approx. 81 drops)

Ingredient	Amount	DV
Black Walnut (Juglans nigra L.) Hull Extract (2,000 mg (1:1) Dry Herb Equivalent)	2,000 mg	†

† Daily Value not established

Other Ingredients Analysis

Analysis of inactive ingredients for dietary restrictions, allergens, and artificial additives.

Black Walnut Hulls, 100 Vegan Capsules (450 mg per Capsule)

Nature's Way

100

Excellent

Other Ingredients

Plant-derived capsule (hypromellose), cellulose.

Positives

Appears vegan-friendlyNo artificial colors or flavors detectedNo common allergens

Black Walnut Hull, Fluid Extract, Alcohol-Free, 2,000 mg, 1 fl oz (30 mL)

Nature's Answer

100

Excellent

Other Ingredients

Vegetable glycerin, usp purified water.

Warnings

Contains glycerin (may not be vegan)

Positives

No artificial colors or flavors detectedNo common allergens

How Clean Score is Calculated

Each positive: +5 points

Each warning or concern: −10 points

Serving Information

Detail	Black Walnut Hulls, 100 Vegan Capsules (450 mg per Capsule)	Black Walnut Hull, Fluid Extract, Alcohol-Free, 2,000 mg, 1 fl oz (30 mL)
Serving Size	2 Capsules	2 mL (approx. 81 drops)
Servings Per Container	50	15
Package Quantity	100 count	1 fl oz

Certifications & Claims

Black Walnut Hulls, 100 Vegan Capsules (450 mg per Capsule)

Non-GMOGluten-FreeVegan

Black Walnut Hull, Fluid Extract, Alcohol-Free, 2,000 mg, 1 fl oz (30 mL)

Gluten-FreeKosher

Browse more comparisons in

Compare Black Walnut Supplements: Ingredients & Supplement Facts

Nature's Way Black Walnut Hull vs Nature's Answer Black Walnut Hulls

Black Walnut Hulls, 100 Vegan Capsules (450 mg per Capsule)

Black Walnut Hull, Fluid Extract, Alcohol-Free, 2,000 mg, 1 fl oz (30 mL)

At a Glance

Verdict

Who each is for

Nature's Way Black Walnut Hull

Nature's Answer Black Walnut Hulls

What you get from each

At a Glance

Ingredient Comparison

Total mg Per Serving

Black Walnut Hulls, 100 Vegan Capsules (450 mg per Capsule)

Black Walnut Hulls, 100 Vegan Capsules (450 mg per Capsule)

Black Walnut Hull, Fluid Extract, Alcohol-Free, 2,000 mg, 1 fl oz (30 mL)

Black Walnut Hull, Fluid Extract, Alcohol-Free, 2,000 mg, 1 fl oz (30 mL)

Other Ingredients Analysis

Black Walnut Hulls, 100 Vegan Capsules (450 mg per Capsule)

Black Walnut Hull, Fluid Extract, Alcohol-Free, 2,000 mg, 1 fl oz (30 mL)

Serving Information

Certifications & Claims

Browse more comparisons in

At a Glance

Verdict

Who each is for

Nature's Way Black Walnut Hull

Nature's Answer Black Walnut Hulls

What you get from each

Nature's Way Black Walnut Hull

Nature's Answer Black Walnut Hulls

Key Differences